The 75 and ZT Owners Club Forums

The 75 and ZT Owners Club Forums (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/index.php)
-   The 75 and ZT Owners Club General Forum (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   Rear Upper Arms (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?t=327712)

sln8458 20th April 2024 11:10

Rear Upper Arms
 
Has anyone come across STARLINE rear upper uspension arm?
Available from ECP.

xsport 20th April 2024 13:25

Get the ones from dmgrs . He has some specials listed that have been worked. You know what your getting. .. ;)

Rogue 20th April 2024 14:55

agree with the above.. I have found Starline not to be of the best quality.

CDT Player 22nd April 2024 01:55

Another shout here for the DMGRS ones they may cost more than the Starline ones but the DMGRS are quality parts.

Until your post I hadn't heard of Starline let alone their 75 upper rears. I was only aware of three after market ones the DMGRS, Indian or Chinese ones. These Starline ones must be new to the market and are likely untested with us 75/ZT owners.

Go for the DMGRS ones plus you're supporting a company that specially caters for the Rover 75/MG ZT (plus 25/45/ZR/ZS).

Arctic 22nd April 2024 10:15

Quote:

Quote:

Originally Posted by sln8458 (Post 2994164)
Has anyone come across STARLINE rear upper uspension arm?
Available from ECP.


I would say avoid these they are most likely renamed Indian ones, i doubt any more have been made by someone else since, there are thousands of Indian ones out there that sellers are stuck with.

Are yours anywhere near the one below.

https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/for...73#post2994273

sln8458 22nd April 2024 10:34

Hi Steve,

ATM, I believe the answer is NO.
Looked ok last I was under the car. but I know these are a potential issue and I am planning to drop the subframe etc during the summer for some TLC as the car is 19yrs old, so just looking around for parts. I know that I have a broken spring (about 1/4 turn has separated from the bottom of one) so need to replace both (hence my post on the springs). Got a subframe sorted, (thanks Andy) got a pair replacement shocks in the garage, so now looking around for the arms.

I know that DMGRS have had some made to their 'revised' spec and that they get good reviews. However that does not mean that the STARLINE ones are rubbish, though they may be. Since I have NO direct experience with any STARLINE products I though I would ask.

Arctic 22nd April 2024 11:20

Quote:

Quote:

Originally Posted by sln8458 (Post 2994279)
Hi Steve,

ATM, I believe the answer is NO.
Looked ok last I was under the car. but I know these are a potential issue and I am planning to drop the subframe etc during the summer for some TLC as the car is 19yrs old, so just looking around for parts. I know that I have a broken spring (about 1/4 turn has separated from the bottom of one) so need to replace both (hence my post on the springs). Got a subframe sorted, (thanks Andy) got a pair replacement shocks in the garage, so now looking around for the arms.

I know that DMGRS have had some made to their 'revised' spec and that they get good reviews. However that does not mean that the STARLINE ones are rubbish, though they may be. Since I have NO direct experience with any STARLINE products I though I would ask.


Hi Stephen.
I see therefore it maybe worth asking ECP a few questions, where they are made, and by whom, wouldn't it be great if we had try before you buy :D:D

I did my rear subframe and upper lower arms including the roll bar, drop links on the tourer just before i sold it.

I managed to get hold of a sub frame from seller whom them from Spain which had all the above attached.

Treated and painted the whole lots a couple of coats.

https://i.imgur.com/eZm6A1Ul.jpg1

https://i.imgur.com/MVP5BOel.jpg2

https://i.imgur.com/UpxSKL5l.jpg3

https://i.imgur.com/8eHoLeDl.jpg4

Made a wooden jig to lift it up level, also used some all thread bolted into the subframe has guides to make sure it went onto the subframe correctly, they have just been borrowed to Devlish whom is doing his this come few weeks.
https://i.imgur.com/ydtQjAml.jpg5

https://i.imgur.com/nAqRktTl.jpg6

New bolts and washers used also.
https://i.imgur.com/owKalMjl.jpg7

My arms when taken off.
https://i.imgur.com/FhpQBDml.jpg8

When they got poked a little.
https://i.imgur.com/48mLXfUl.jpg9

None of the above was seem or noticed until i poked into the cup after a spring broke.

sln8458 22nd April 2024 12:46

Hi Steve,

Your last 2 pics are what I fear.
My plan is similar to yours, get the bits and prep/assemble prior to taking my old stuff out. Though I have found out that I don't need the rear droplinks I have already purchased:duh: Then another thought I have had, is that if I can't get the correct springs (RM violet) and end up going back to the original springs, should I re-instate the torsion bar???


PS: what's with the gold paint?? or is that gold leaf :)

vitesse 23rd April 2024 08:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arctic (Post 2994275)
I would say avoid these they are most likely renamed Chinese ones, i doubt any more have been made by someone else since, there are thousands of Chinese ones out there that sellers are stuck with.

Not sure I understand your post, 1000s of Chinese ones? Weren't the 1000's of unsold stock the Indian ones as tested by MarinaBrian?

DMGRS themselves sold Chinese SAIC upper arms before their own came into production.

I was once part of a group buy and because of differing production, DMGRS wanted to supply me with one Chinese and one Indian one, I refused, insisting on the Chinese SAIC ones which I got. At the time the Chinese SAIC one were considered as OEM. I then heard that the tooling had been destroyed.

I've now got a set of new DMGRS ones up in the attic (although we don't know where they are made).

Keep well

Arctic 23rd April 2024 18:41

[QUOTE]
Quote:

Originally Posted by vitesse (Post 2994370)
Not sure I understand your post, 1000s of Chinese ones? Weren't the 1000's of unsold stock the Indian ones as tested by MarinaBrian?

DMGRS themselves sold Chinese SAIC upper arms before their own came into production.

I was once part of a group buy and because of differing production, DMGRS wanted to supply me with one Chinese and one Indian one, I refused, insisting on the Chinese SAIC ones which I got. At the time the Chinese SAIC one were considered as OEM. I then heard that the tooling had been destroyed.

I've now got a set of new DMGRS ones up in the attic (although we don't know where they are made).

HI Mike.
Yes sorry my bad it should read Indian arms :duh:


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:32.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright © 2006-2023, The Rover 75 & MG ZT Owners Club Ltd