The 75 and ZT Owners Club Forums

The 75 and ZT Owners Club Forums (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/index.php)
-   The 75 and ZT Owners Club General Forum (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   Disappointed (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?t=291171)

MSS 11th January 2019 16:40

Thank Brian, useful information but tangential to my point.

As you know, maufacturing processes often change for an OEM part during a product's life. Often in order to reduce cost.

The pertinent question remains - is the FAG bearing based item now the OEM standard, or do SNR still manufacture the "original production OEM" standard part?

The questionable longevity of the part that Mat played with could be for all sorts of reasons, including rubbish materials being used in the manufacture as is now the case very often.

marinabrian 11th January 2019 18:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by mss (Post 2701591)
Thank Brian, useful information but tangential to my point.

As you know, maufacturing processes often change for an OEM part during a product's life. Often in order to reduce cost.

The pertinent question remains - is the FAG bearing based item now the OEM standard, or do SNR still manufacture the "original production OEM" standard part?

The questionable longevity of the part that Mat played with could be for all sorts of reasons, including rubbish materials being used in the manufacture as is now the case very often.

I would say that the SNR bearing in original format is still available, I bought two fairly recently LINK


These are the original production standard part, and not some Micky Mouse effort made by the Guang Dong Bearing, Lawn mower, and Dangerous Toy Company.

So if the OP wishes to fit a component in every way as good quality as fitted on the production line, let's just say a perfect facsimile, then the link is there to the supplier I used to obtain mine ;)

Brian :D

Typhoon190 11th January 2019 19:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by marinabrian (Post 2701636)
I would say that the SNR bearing in original format is still available, I bought two fairly recently LINK


These are the original production standard part, and not some Micky Mouse effort made by the Guang Dong Bearing, Lawn mower, and Dangerous Toy Company.

So if the OP wishes to fit a component in every way as good quality as fitted on the production line, let's just say a perfect facsimile, then the link is there to the supplier I used to obtain mine ;)

Brian :D

Thanks Brian.

Much appreciated. 3rd time lucky hopefully.

I have no issue with the FAG bearing as such, however as Brian has pointed out, the manufacturing process achieves a lower quality product.

I think we all just wish that manufacturers, suppliers etc just sold what they advertise, and advertise what they sell instead of misrepresenting things.

ceetdm 14th June 2021 09:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by marinabrian (Post 2701636)
I would say that the SNR bearing in original format is still available, I bought two fairly recently LINK


These are the original production standard part, and not some Micky Mouse effort made by the Guang Dong Bearing, Lawn mower, and Dangerous Toy Company.

So if the OP wishes to fit a component in every way as good quality as fitted on the production line, let's just say a perfect facsimile, then the link is there to the supplier I used to obtain mine ;)

Brian :D

I've just bought two of the rear SNR hubs/bearings using Brian's recommendation in the link above (used AutoDoc app got 40% discount today).

Can anyone tell me if I am likely to get this original/genuine part or are they going to be a cheap version with the external reluctor ring clipped on? I might just have to wait to find out what I get, but was hoping someone has purchased them recently?

Tommy :-)

ceedy 14th June 2021 09:44

Not trying to crucify Reamers any more but the last wheel bearing fitted to my ZT was supposedly from them and marked as a SNR , and that lasted 4500 k miles . and after I sent the duffer to SNR for checking ,twas declared " not one of ours" :eek:. but that might have been them sloping shoulders..
Did get a refund ..


Replaced with a FAG and 50 k miles on so far ..

Mind the original OEM on the NS is 163+ k miles ;)



C

DMGRS 14th June 2021 16:41

The originals seem to last like nothing else - absolutely gutted that I didn't buy all 2,700 on 4 pallets I was offered 5 years ago!
I'd be able to retire by now :D

Quality is very variable it seems - we're working on a bearing made by the OE supplier to SAIC MG coming over in the next few months, but thanks to the shipping shortages we have no ETA yet.
We do know it'll cost £59.99 and have an unlimited mileage 4 year warranty (and no clip on magnetic ring) though! :cool:

Arctic 14th June 2021 23:08

I have these in my stock just in case one of mine go rouge

https://i.imgur.com/Xjle6Qul.jpg1

https://i.imgur.com/KhPmcyZl.jpg2

https://i.imgur.com/cDvgGAll.jpg3

I am hoping they will be good as the original Rover ones.

ceedy 15th June 2021 12:02

Still got a FAG Bearing from DMGRS in its box spare just in case ..



And Not yet fitted so probably wasted most of its 5 year warranty :duh: :D



c

DMGRS 15th June 2021 13:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by ceedy (Post 2886582)
Still got a FAG Bearing from DMGRS in its box spare just in case ..



And Not yet fitted so probably wasted most of its 5 year warranty :duh: :D



c

Don't worry, those are excellent and you certainly won't need the warranty! :D

bl52krz 15th June 2021 21:29

We have it in our own hands. Just don’t buy from suppliers that abuse your intelligence. I will never buy anything with the name Delphi on it .......ever, after buying c@%p drop links.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright © 2006-2023, The Rover 75 & MG ZT Owners Club Ltd