The 75 and ZT Owners Club Forums

The 75 and ZT Owners Club Forums (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/index.php)
-   Technical Help Forum (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Diesel thermostat definative answer (https://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?t=68468)

clf 22nd February 2015 01:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arctic (Post 1927864)
Hi Alan.
I thought you could just twist the stat out from the hosing and change the stat alone, I could be wrong Arctic

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/PBM100040-...item5646b00dd4

I too could be wrong, Arctic, I haven' done the task myself. but I base what I said on discussions throughout the site, both on the diesel stat, and v6 one. I did make the suggestion of removing the unit from the housing, on a v6, but whatever way it is attached to the housing, would cause it to leak if removed.

Arctic 22nd February 2015 02:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by clf (Post 1927866)
I too could be wrong, Arctic, I haven' done the task myself. but I base what I said on discussions throughout the site, both on the diesel stat, and v6 one. I did make the suggestion of removing the unit from the housing, on a v6, but whatever way it is attached to the housing, would cause it to leak if removed.

Hi Alan.
Yes V6 thermostat housing is a sealed one, but the Diesel as an open housing so the thermostat should be able to be exchanged, weather it is cost effective to do that ivwould not know, wonder who will be first to try :}

wuzerk 22nd February 2015 10:35

diesel Thermostat
 
I removed an original diesel thermostat from its housing several times during my experiments and there is no problem with refitting it although it does require a fair bit of pressure to do so.

Arctic 22nd February 2015 10:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by wuzerk (Post 1928080)
I removed an original diesel thermostat from its housing several times during my experiments and there is no problem with refitting it although it does require a fair bit of pressure to do so.

Excellent we now have our answer, was it cost effect ie was the rubber gasket ok in the housing etc as from what I can see that is all that can go wrong or is there a O-ring to fit also, with just fitting the thermostat we/you could find a stat with maybe a 92c opening ?and replace the original 88c one that is fitted into them at the moment cheers Arctic.

wuzerk 22nd February 2015 11:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arctic (Post 1928084)
Excellent we now have our answer, was it cost effect ie was the rubber gasket ok in the housing etc as from what I can see that is all that can go wrong or is there a O-ring to fit also, with just fitting the thermostat we/you could find a stat with maybe a 92c opening ?and replace the original 88c one that is fitted into them at the moment cheers Arctic.

I hope we haven't go a crossed line here Dave. The Original Rover housings
do develop a leak sometimes as reported on this site but I do not know if that is due to a faulty rubber seal or the O ring around the feed pipe. The thermostat itself is a special type and will not work unless it is fitted into the housing because it does not have the normal 'bridge' against which the piston pushes in order to open. The bridge on the original item is the actual plastic
housing so it only works as a complete assembly.

Mike Noc 22nd February 2015 11:47

I've seen a couple of leaks due to deteriorated seals in the original housings, so given the amount of time it takes to replace the thermostat I'd fit a new housing as well, or at the very least a new seal, if these can be obtained separately, and a new O ring for the pipe.

HarryM1BYT 22nd February 2015 12:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Noc (Post 1928131)
I've seen a couple of leaks due to deteriorated seals in the original housings, so given the amount of time it takes to replace the thermostat I'd fit a new housing as well, or at the very least a new seal, if these can be obtained separately, and a new O ring for the pipe.

This came under discussion many years ago - the conclusion arrived at was that a replacement for the stat insert for the housing (just the stat insert), could not be sourced.

The only way to replace the stat, is either a complete unit - housing and stat, or if just the stat has simply begun to open early, fit a top hose stat mod.

T-Cut 22nd February 2015 12:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by HarryM1BYT (Post 1928147)
This came under discussion many years ago - the conclusion arrived at was that a replacement for the stat insert for the housing (just the stat insert), could not be sourced.

That's correct, the diesel stat module won't operate without the housing. They are an assembly that isn't available as individual parts.

TC

DMGRS 22nd February 2015 13:02

PBM100040 is a different thermostat to the item fitted to our cars - the insert in PEL100570 is a different shape, although they are similar.

Early reports of the 'V3' item I have are good, although it'll be years before we know for sure. They're a lot cheaper than the OEM item though.
PEL100570 - 'V3'

I'll grab a picture of PBM100040 and PEL100570 inserts together to show the difference. :)

Arctic 22nd February 2015 13:56

I have just taken a closer look at the thermostat I have in front of me and you can definitely remove the thermostat insert by twisting it out, so it should be able to be replaced.

Thermostat pushed/squashed down and held in with the aid of the clip on the housing Fig 1

http://i62.tinypic.com/2hz2wkx.jpg1

The housing as these fixing points both sides Fig 2
http://i60.tinypic.com/adgqz5.jpg2

Where the O-ring would fit Fig 3
http://i58.tinypic.com/30blkxe.jpg3

Internal fixing for the thermostat Fig 4
http://i57.tinypic.com/2s81xt3.jpg4

Hole in the thermostat Fig 5
http://i58.tinypic.com/seq446.jpg5

Last the housing rubber gasket Fig 6
http://i58.tinypic.com/21c5jzo.jpg6

As you can see these fit both the R75 FL 1 and the Rover city
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/4005223256...%3AMEBIDX%3AIT

I was wondering if this would fit below 92c I will find out by purchasing one next week ;)
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/VAUXHALL-C...99328255?rt=nc

The PMB100040 looks to be the same to me as the one in the hosing above
http://www.brit-car.co.uk/search.php?xSearch=PBM100040

FrenchMike 22nd February 2015 15:24

The only critical part is the wax bulb ....

Lot of cogitations about it ...3 years ago:


http://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/foru...ght=Thermostat

Mike

fbzr 20th May 2015 11:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arctic (Post 1928285)

Hole in the thermostat Fig 5
http://i58.tinypic.com/seq446.jpg5

Hi,

Is necessary to open a small hole in the inline thermostat?

Regards,
FB

Union Wheels 20th May 2015 11:54

Hi fbzr,
the answer is "no" If you do the engine will not reach the required temperature.

Pete.

T-Cut 20th May 2015 12:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by fbzr (Post 2003959)
Is necessary to open a small hole in the inline thermostat?

The tests done with and without a bleed hole with the in-line stat indicates it has a significant effect on running temperature (reduced). Obviously, the size of the effect depends on the size of the hole. I'd anticipate a similar effect with the default type, but I'm not aware of any tests with it.

TC

Jules 20th May 2015 12:01

No hole required
We've fitted many of these stats with no issues
(other than we don't fit them to cars which are likely to tow a caravan due to the fact the inline stat is 30% smaller than OEM)

In certain circumstances the extra maximum flow of the OEM is required when towing up hill on a very hot day for example!

Without the bleed hole the system won't fully self bleed until the first warm up trip has been completed.
You might see the temp rise once to 105deg C but once the air pockets from the top hose have pumped back into the header tank everything will be fine after that.
Don't forget to pressure check to 10 PSI or check for leaks after the first few trips. ;)

fbzr 20th May 2015 13:50

Thanks for the answers ...and excellent modification...and explanation :bowdown:

The hole was even the bleeding of air pockets ... nothing else ...

With the inline stat the temp gauge keeps in 9 o'clock or moves between 8 and 9 o'clock?

Regards,
FB

T-Cut 20th May 2015 15:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by fbzr (Post 2004052)
With the inline stat the temp gauge keeps in 9 o'clock or moves between 8 and 9 o'clock?

That suggests the variation is between 65C and 75C, which is too low. Run the Trip screen Diagnostic Mode to see the actual temperatures.

TC

fbzr 22nd May 2015 14:55

...one more diesel with inline stat :D

Installation:

Stainless band cut (dremel)
http://i59.tinypic.com/oumlh0.jpg


The inline stat (Vernet 89°C)
http://i57.tinypic.com/fb03g4.jpg


Let's go!
http://i57.tinypic.com/1z20qbr.jpg


With fairy detergent, hot water, steel pipe (great help) and a lot of strength ...stat slid ...
http://i58.tinypic.com/wanifa.jpg


Within 5 cm...
http://i58.tinypic.com/2428sjl.jpg


Done! The second clamp is for the stat does not slide
http://i59.tinypic.com/2gsil2o.jpg

The result was the first 40 miles temperature was maintained between 84-89ºC.


One question, someone has already withdrawn the stat to replace it? It should be a very hard work too.


Regard,
FB

Jules 22nd May 2015 15:22

Oh dear No need to push it in that far or remove the hose!

The copper wax bulb needs to be as close to engine block as possible fot accurate temperature detection.

With the correct rubber lubricant (synthetic based not fairy liquid) they can be removed.

We just removed an inline stat today because a new water pump was being fitted and while dismantled we recommended for not much extra a new OEM stat could be fitted.
Owner said yes please so the deed was done. :)

fbzr 22nd May 2015 16:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jules (Post 2005645)
The copper wax bulb needs to be as close to engine block as possible fot accurate temperature detection.

:}
...The copper wax bulb is 10mm inside the plastic inion :shrug:

...When I have to replace the water pump stat inline will leave too ;)

Regard,
FB

Mike Noc 22nd May 2015 19:44

If you are going to remove the old thermostat housing and fit it to the new water pump check the seal - they have a habit of leaking along with the O ring for the pipe. ;)

Personally I'd fit a new 'stat, but each to their own. :D

Fred7A 15th August 2015 19:39

I see there's a huge thread on this subject! My 2003 CDT's temperature never reaches the 9 o'clock position and fluctuates considerably wile driving. As far as I can see from here it needs a new thermostat. Is that the only possible cause, or does anything else need investigating as well?

wullie480 15th August 2015 19:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fred7A (Post 2072117)
I see there's a huge thread on this subject! My 2003 CDT's temperature never reaches the 9 o'clock position and fluctuates considerably wile driving. As far as I can see from here it needs a new thermostat. Is that the only possible cause, or does anything else need investigating as well?

Yes your thermostat is at fault.

You can see the actual temp via the on board diagnostic.

clf 15th August 2015 19:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fred7A (Post 2072117)
I see there's a huge thread on this subject! My 2003 CDT's temperature never reaches the 9 o'clock position and fluctuates considerably wile driving. As far as I can see from here it needs a new thermostat. Is that the only possible cause, or does anything else need investigating as well?

check the temp using the on board display, I think the technique is on this thread somewhere. if it is below 80 degrees, then thermostat is most likely issue. inserting the Renault 5 stat will be the quickest and easiest method of finding out if it is another issue with the cooling system. (although I cannot imagine what that would be to cause it to run too cool )

Fred7A 15th August 2015 20:17

Wow, those were really quick replies! :bowdown:

I'll look up how to run the on-board display and check it out - many thanks to you both. :}

wullie480 15th August 2015 20:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fred7A (Post 2072152)
Wow, those were really quick replies! :bowdown:

I'll look up how to run the on-board display and check it out - many thanks to you both. :}

T-Cut done a thread on it http://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/foru...iagnostic+mode

suzublu 15th August 2015 20:28

And a video here ;) http://www.the75andztclub.co.uk/foru...d.php?t=185808

Fred7A 16th August 2015 21:18

Thanks for the guide, it's easy when you know how! I ran the diagnostics and gave the car a quick run up the motorway for a few miles. The temperature stayed in the low 60s most of the time, with 67 the highest. That's a lot lower than it should be, so I'm guessing that confirms the thermostat not working properly.

On the plus side I checked the plenum drain and everything is nice and dry, and I gave my cloudy headlights a good rub-down and polish - still not perfect but definitely improved.

I see there's a system here for thanking other posters, but I can't work out how to use it... :duh:

KRISTLEE 16th August 2015 21:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fred7A (Post 2073092)
I see there's a system here for thanking other posters, but I can't work out how to use it... :duh:

I believe once you have reached 10 posts the clicky button will be available to use for thanking others..

I have recently changed my thermostat out as I had to do the water pump and it's a bit of a pig of a job to be honest even using the excellent guidance on here. Being ambidextrous and a contortionist would be a huge bonus but for us lesser mortals the key is ensuring that your trolley jack can give enough lift when raising the engine so you can get to the bolts easy enough. Also having an E8 torx spanner comes in very handy if you don't have the lift and can't get enough room for sockets.

If it's just the thermostat at fault then if I were you I would just do the in-line mod for the same result needed.

Fred7A 16th August 2015 22:36

Unfortunately I don't have the facilities for doing any real work myself, so I'd have to get a garage to do it. As I only bought the car recently I want to get a good service booked in, so my plan is to get the thermostat done at the same time. My local garage is pretty good, but can anyone recommend a Rover specialist near to Southampton?

KRISTLEE 16th August 2015 23:27

I did mine in the front street lol...I wish I wasn't so stubborn and refuse to pay garage costs and I had just got my car recovered to a garage and let them do it as they wouldn't have had to worry if it was going to rain or whatever and they would've done it in no time on a lift with the proper tools etc...next big job is definitely getting done in a garage lol.

I'm sure someone else will be along soon enough to advise you of a specialist garage in the Southampton area...

Fred7A 16th August 2015 23:59

You're obviously less cack-handed than I am Lee! I've never been very good at DIY mechanics, even when I was running "basic" cars like my old Wolseley 1500.

Fred7A 4th September 2015 18:38

Well the thermostat is now fixed and my temperature gauge is sitting nicely at 9 o'clock. :D

I had it done at MG Rover World in Shedfield, which I found mentioned on an old thread here. Very pleased with the work carried out, which included a service, and there was the added bonus of a Rover 75 courtesy car. It was a 1.8 - not having driven a petrol one before it made my diesel feel a little agricultural in comparison!

On the downside, I've managed to pick up a nail in one of my tyres. Luckily the car has a "proper" spare, with an unused tyre, but as it's steel it doesn't match the other wheels very well... :duh:

T-Cut 4th September 2015 19:42

Which reminds me. Has anyone got an update on the performance of the 'Mk3' stat from DMGRS?

Maybe it's not been in use long enough yet, but it would be interesting to compare the longevity of Mk1, 2 and 3. As far as I'm aware, the Mk1s are still going strong though maybe few in number(?). The Mk2s are the reason for this 140 page thread and the Mk3s are hopefully an OEM style permanent fix.

TC

BadgeStar 28th January 2016 18:40

Just to make this thread a little longer ....... having read the first 'umpteen' pages of it and then skipping to the last dozen pages, to save me traipsing through the other 99 pages I wonder if someone could answer a question for me please?
.....if I was to buy an in-line (aluminium?) thermostat housing as seen on eBay from Specialist Components can anybody advise on whether I would need a small hole in the thermostat or not? :confused:

Barry.

Union Wheels 28th January 2016 18:57

Hi BadgeStar,

definitely not.

No hole required

Pete.

DMGRS 28th January 2016 19:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by T-Cut (Post 2088971)
Which reminds me. Has anyone got an update on the performance of the 'Mk3' stat from DMGRS?

Maybe it's not been in use long enough yet, but it would be interesting to compare the longevity of Mk1, 2 and 3. As far as I'm aware, the Mk1s are still going strong though maybe few in number(?). The Mk2s are the reason for this 140 page thread and the Mk3s are hopefully an OEM style permanent fix.

TC

I know any data from myself will be 'biased', but no reported issues or returns yet.
Still working well on the 4 we fitted to test. :)

PaulR 28th January 2016 20:14

I can certainly recommend the inline housing. It is a very high quality unit. Mine has been fitted since the early days of this thread and continues to work perfectly.

Gren 24 28th January 2016 20:42

I've had my Diesel Thermostat Fitted for about a year now from DMGRS and very pleased with it on my 2004 CTDI Tourer.

It was really good in the summer and now with the cold mornings and nights I could not fault it.My Tourer runs at the temp it should.

I'm pleased I did not go with the in line, but that's just me. Each to there own.


T-Cut 28th January 2016 21:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gren 24 (Post 2206754)
My Tourer runs at the temp it should.

Have you got the numbers so we can compare?

TC

Jules 28th January 2016 21:15

Do not drill a hole.
The system is self bleeding once the stat opens for the first time.

ie
You may see the temp rise to 110C once after refil then a sudden drop to 88C

Busboy 28th January 2016 21:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frank Incensed (Post 585930)
Well done on getting the response, even if it's not what we were hoping for.

I'm still trying to find an alternative thermostat and I'm off to my local parts dept tomorrow, with what I've found. But BMW's reply that it would'nt make any difference doesn't bode well. This is born out by tales of good mpg obtained by members with stuck-open thermostats.

As for the motor being too (thermally) efficient, then why does it use so much diesel for the power output? As T-Cut said, it seems the cooling system is the thing that's too efficient! James' idea of restricting the air flow to the radiator has been put to me by others and currently seems the best solution. Perhaps someone can devise a way of diverting some of the air blasting through the grille into the air intake.

Hmmm! This is a long and very technical thread, I have a vested interest because I have a late CDTi.

As a more aged member, I recall that when I had classic cars in the 1970's /80's some of them had black leather radiator muffs fitted, which greatly helped in reducing cold air flow when driving off in the winter with an ice cold engine. Also London Transport even used a sliding steel panel on the RT Type double decker bus that could be risen in cold weather to reduce air flow, as the 1939 AEC engine was also thermally efficient, so there you have it folks, 2 vehicles 60 years difference and technicnically streets apart but one common souoution , Stick a muff on the front, I have and it works a treat!!! :cool::}
;)

Jules 28th January 2016 22:05

A radiator blind may help the running temp in certain circumstances but it won't make any difference to the warm up time because there is no coolant flow through the rad during this phase until the stat starts to open.

Busboy 28th January 2016 22:15

Thanks for your reply Jules, I will let you play around with my car when I come up to see you later in the year!

clf 28th January 2016 22:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jules (Post 2206833)
A radiator blind may help the running temp in certain circumstances but it won't make any difference to the warm up time because there is no coolant flow through the rad during this phase until the stat starts to open.

I can attest to this, having blocked off my upper and lower grilles, with duct tape. Although it did increase the running temp literally by a couple of degrees, it simply wouldnt be worth it.

BadgeStar 29th January 2016 03:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jules (Post 2206785)
Do not drill a hole.
The system is self bleeding once the stat opens for the first time.

ie
You may see the temp rise to 110C once after refil then a sudden drop to 88C

Thanks Jules ..... Bleeding was my next question!:}

Barry.

PaulR 29th January 2016 08:08

I cut pieces of corrugated plastic sheet (the type you get pinned to the garden wall advertising the builder when you have had new windows or similar) to shape. These just slot in nicely behind the radiator grille to form an invisible radiator muff, admittedly only covering half the radiator. I used it during the very cold winters we had a few years ago and felt that it did help to keep the engine warm when the heater was running, but it might have been wishful thinking!

FrenchMike 29th January 2016 08:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by PaulR (Post 2207011)
I cut pieces of corrugated plastic sheet (the type you get pinned to the garden wall advertising the builder when you have had new windows or similar) to shape. These just slot in nicely behind the radiator grille to form an invisible radiator muff, admittedly only covering half the radiator. I used it during the very cold winters we had a few years ago and felt that it did help to keep the engine warm when the heater was running, but it might have been wishful thinking!

IMHO,it'useless as the role of the thermostat is to maintain the engine temp
by allowing more or less coolant through the radiator ...:shrug:

paulf 10th July 2016 18:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by paulf (Post 628454)
This seems a worthwhile mod for those with thermostat problems but has anyone thought of using a Renault in hose stat?.It seems to be a common mod on Vauxhalls to avoid removing the cam belt when the thermostat packs up.
My thermostat seems marginal at present as its running at 80 to 83c and if it gets worse im going to try an 88c Renault 5 thermostat in the top hose.
Paul

Well 6 years latter I finally replaced my 300,000 mile 1999 cdt with a 2004 cdti and the first thing I found when I had it on the road after replacing clutch and front suspension bushes and strut top bearings, was that it didnt warm up. Even on a hot day it only got to a quarter on the gauge and returned 42mpg and so finally got to try the mod for myself today, it now gets to normal on the gauge in a couple of miles and engine response is a lot better, I just need to see what effect it has on fuel consumption as my old car used to average 49 to 50 mpg.
Paul

paulf 10th July 2016 18:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by T-Cut (Post 2088971)
Which reminds me. Has anyone got an update on the performance of the 'Mk3' stat from DMGRS?

Maybe it's not been in use long enough yet, but it would be interesting to compare the longevity of Mk1, 2 and 3. As far as I'm aware, the Mk1s are still going strong though maybe few in number(?). The Mk2s are the reason for this 140 page thread and the Mk3s are hopefully an OEM style permanent fix.

TC

I assume that my 1999 car was a mk1 thermostat as I have owned the car for 7 years and never had a problem with it, my replacement is a 2004 car and the thermostat had failed.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:17.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright © 2006-2023, The Rover 75 & MG ZT Owners Club Ltd