Quote:
Originally Posted by SD1too
Hi Steve,
I would do that if I was changing down without braking because I wanted better vehicle control or was anticipating brisk acceleration. Conversely, if I was braking I wouldn't blip the throttle as I'm seeking to use engine braking to assist my retardation.
I don't see that as an advantage of the modern teaching method. My foot will be in the right place (over the brake) but crucially I will already be in the appropriate gear when the other car accelerates past the junction whilst you will be engaged in a thought process of what to do next.  
That's a good point Steve. The driver changed his/her mind because the road on the right was not the route required after all. We've all done it haven't we. I absolutely agree that I should then be anticipating a further attempt to turn right and so I should not accelerate quickly. However that is no reason NOT to change down through the gearbox! I am in the correct gear for maximum vehicle control so I am ready to both come to a standstill (if the driver in front turns right) or to continue under controlled acceleration (if the other driver does likewise). It seems to me that the modern method would place me in a situation of complete indecision until the scenario plays out in front of me. With the traditional method I am already prepared for whatever may happen.
The modern world does not appreciate that some things work well because they are the best way of dealing with a situation that has been correctly assessed and no changes are desirable or necessary.
Simon |
I think you are doing yourself an injustice. You certainly don't sound indecisive! What it really comes down to, is just different styles of driving. I prefer the "new" style and find it works very well. You drive in the older style which obviously works for you. I think what you and I want is just safe driving and there is nothing to make either method less safe. The only real issue would be if you retook your driving test as you would be marked down for use of gears, but that is really just pedantises.