|
||
|
18th March 2019, 17:41 | #1 |
Gets stuck in
Rover 75 saloon Join Date: Dec 2018
Location: Maxton, Dover
Posts: 519
Thanks: 183
Thanked 132 Times in 89 Posts
|
HGF ... what is the deal ?
Perhaps this isn't the place to put this but as the engine is used in the 75 also, i'm betting it's a very common problem for 75 / ZT owners too!?... is there a definitive and permanent fix for the K series HGF?
I'm asking this because I have for a long time been wanting an MGF but have heard and seen quite a few horror stories and although reading and researching so many theories on the subject I now feel overwhelmed by the amount of conflicting evidence for the cure / fix. I really don't want to be messing around with trying to fix something that ultimately can't be cured. Is the HGF something that can be sorted permanently or will I have to live in fear of the inevitable? Any qualified opinions and first hand experience of this problem would be a big help in deciding whether to go ahead and buy one or not, I don't mind buying one and then having to sort it at some point as long as whatever has to be done to it is a permanent fix. |
18th March 2019, 18:25 | #2 |
This is my second home
Roverless + 1.7D Sportage Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: East Norfolk
Posts: 7,050
Thanks: 729
Thanked 2,021 Times in 1,449 Posts
|
Everything depends on the condition of the unit involved. If the liners are sound and level, use the steel multilayer. If there is any uneveness in the liners, use the uprated standard gasket. That's a very simplistic explanation. There are also upgrades for a stiffened oil rail etc., I would suggest a trawl of the net for the full info. It's not straightforward and you need a specialist to give you the best advice once the engine is stripped for inspection. There is no fixed answer to your questions.
__________________
Oil in my veins! |
18th March 2019, 19:25 | #3 | |
Gets stuck in
Rover 75 saloon Join Date: Dec 2018
Location: Maxton, Dover
Posts: 519
Thanks: 183
Thanked 132 Times in 89 Posts
|
Quote:
Ie ... the fitting of all these uprated parts should in theory negate the need to do it again in the future or will there always be room for doubt taking into account the inherent design flaws of the engine design? What I can't find the answer to is ....those complete engine re-builds that have used all the modified parts ... how well they have faired 50-60,000 miles down the road! |
|
18th March 2019, 19:46 | #4 |
This is my second home
None Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: None
Posts: 5,556
Thanks: 465
Thanked 1,161 Times in 924 Posts
|
It's a great question, and I hope you find a definitive answer, if you do then I may consider the 1.8. At the moment diesels are unfashionable and alternatives will have to be sought.
|
18th March 2019, 20:06 | #5 |
This is my second home
Rover75 and Mreg Corsa. Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sumweer onat mote o'dust (Sagin)
Posts: 21,753
Thanks: 341
Thanked 3,660 Times in 2,924 Posts
|
IMO, the underlying cause of the K18s vulnerability is in the cooling system rather than in the engine design. It's said to be the best power pack ever developed by MGR, but it certainly needs more TLC than most others. This above all refers to coolant sytem maintenance and thereby, the running temperature. In the 75/ZT, there's no way to know the running temperature. I suspect this may be so in the MGF as well. Since the temperature gauge is useless, the engine is vulnerable through the smallest coolant leakage from the plasticky bits bolted to and around it. The inlet manifold, the coolant hose connectors, dodgy cooling fan designs, etc. In 90% of HGFs there will be an unrecognised overheat preceeding it. Other causes like the use of OAT based coolant have been proposed as contributory factors, but again it's loss of coolant that underpins most head gasket issues. Obviously that can't be the only one involved, but I reckon it's by far the main one.
TC |
18th March 2019, 20:43 | #6 | |
Posted a thing or two
Rover 75 Join Date: Sep 2016
Location: Middlesbrough
Posts: 1,518
Thanks: 1,861
Thanked 723 Times in 471 Posts
|
Quote:
|
|
19th March 2019, 09:19 | #7 |
Gets stuck in
75 Tourer CDTi Connie SE Join Date: Jun 2017
Location: Keith, Banffshire
Posts: 686
Thanks: 431
Thanked 132 Times in 105 Posts
|
i had, until recently, a year 2000 Freelander fitted with the 1.8 non turbo K series engine. After only a few months of ownership, it had a suspected HGF and although I drove it, albeit sounding very rough, to the garage, it didnt overheat noticeably. Anyway, the garage diagnosed HGF, suggested the usual fixes as well as an uprated cooling system. They said the original cooling system was the main problem and the thermostat would open, flushing the engine block in cooled water, causing thermal shock and eventual HGF. I found a local garage that dealt with reconditioned 1.8s around London and a refurbished engine was fitted, along with all the improvements, i was amaze how light it was too. It didnt overheat seriously again but the temp needle would start to rise if stuck in traffic, so i never really trusted it anymore.
It seems there are still thousands of individuals involved in a class law suit against land Rover due to the design fault and the fact that even a fixed 1.8 would probably fail again. Many people lost thousands having to have whole engines replaced and why I got rid fairly soon after that. It was a lovely car just spoilt by that one engine, in my view!!
__________________
My 75 Tourer CDTi was born Saturday, 21st June 2003 @ 09:50 My 75 was the 18,749th 75 Tourer to run off the production line, out of 27,407 It was the 195th 75 Tourer CDT Connoisseur SE (135) to be made out of 2,074 and the 1,789th 75 Tourer in Wedgewood Blue Metallic (code: JEL) to be made out of 1,871 Wedgewood Blue Metallic 75 Tourers |
19th March 2019, 09:28 | #8 | |
This is my second home
Rover75 and Mreg Corsa. Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sumweer onat mote o'dust (Sagin)
Posts: 21,753
Thanks: 341
Thanked 3,660 Times in 2,924 Posts
|
Quote:
They introduced the PRT to resolve that specific problem. Unfortunately, relatively few K18s had one. That said, it only resolved the cold shock issue. IMO the leaky cooling system overrides everything. TC |
|
19th March 2019, 09:42 | #9 |
This is my second home
All Trophy Blue ,ZT260#50 , ZT CDTI Auto, ZR105+ and 1.8T Firefrost spoiling the Set . Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Nr Sherborne But in Somerset..
Posts: 6,076
Thanks: 916
Thanked 1,214 Times in 768 Posts
|
HGF if repaired correctly with the right gasket will last ..
Wifeys Zr HG was done at 62k and we are now pushing 120k .. C
__________________
The Three Bloo's Wifey's Zr105, MY CDTI & 260 #50 and Number One sons 1.8T in Firefrost When I were a lad Zero to 142 in 10.25 secs at the Pod on my Blown Norton. 210 Kart Champ in 70's |
19th March 2019, 10:48 | #10 | |
I really should get out more.......
Vauxhall Insignia CDTi; MG TF 135 Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Norn Iron
Posts: 2,958
Thanks: 942
Thanked 378 Times in 297 Posts
|
Quote:
I was offered a minters ’05 TF with 13,000 miles on the clock for less than 3 Grand (not many buyers here in NI), so took a chance and bought it – have to say it’s brought a real smile to my face. I studied endless forums etc, and ended up with a very sore brain, with all the different and sometimes conflicting opinions expressed. But it seems to me that coolant loss is indeed the main contributory factor, as TC suggests. There are other things, eg the rad is at the front, engine at back, 2 long thin pipes conveying coolant to and fro. These can corrode internally, and block – people often fit stainless replacements. But I’m assuming, if the correct coolant is used, car properly serviced by somebody who knows what he’s doing etc, this shouldn’t happen. One thing worth having is a coolant level sensor – at least then you can cut the engine if the light comes on, and hopefully stop it overheating in time. I’m lucky in that my late model has one fitted as standard, but you can buy kits. What’s the issue with OAT, TC? I read up on it and it seems to be appropriate for this motor – don’t tell me it’s not These cars have lots of other irritating (though less serious) issues, just like the 75’s, but I’ve had a lot of help from: https://www.the-t-bar.com/forum/index https://forums.mg-rover.org/mgf-mgtf-12/
__________________
Past cars: MGB GT; Escort 1300 Sport; Vauxhall VX4/90; Marina Coupe TC; Celica ST (1972); Montego Turbo; Astra GTE 16V; Astra GSI 16V; Golf GTI 16V (Mk II); Sierra XR4x4 Estate; BMW 325i (E30); BMW M3 3.0; BMW M3 3.2 Evo. Left some of the more embarrassing ones out. And about 30 motorbikes. |
|
|
|